Neenah Pet Store | Pet Supplies Plus

Independently owned and operated


Sun: 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Mon-Sat: 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM


Pet Supplies Plus
872 Fox Point Plaza
Neenah, WI 54956-3781



About this Store

Pet Supplies Plus is very excited to be joining the Neenah community!! We are here to assist you with all your pet needs. Our store is independently owned and operated. We pride ourselves on giving every one of our neighbors an outstanding experience. We will be offering online ordering with curbside pickup and delivery. On those busy nights rushing home from work, there will be no hassle to pick up or have us deliver Fido's dinner right to your front door. Our online delivery is same day if placed by 1pm. If placed after 1pm, delivery will be next day.



Live Crickets

Our cricket IN STOCK GUARANTEE makes sure your critter always has the nutrition they need!


Visiting Pet Care Clinic

Low cost preventative veterinary care, hours and services vary by location. No appointment necessary.

Learn More >>

Curbside Pickup

Shop with Curbside Pickup to get what you need in as little as one hour without leaving your car.

Learn More >>

VIP Petcare Wellness Center

A wide variety of wellness services in a traditional vet setting including physical exams, vaccinations, heartworm preventative, and more. No appointment necessary.


Deliver from Store

Select Delivery at checkout and your local store will deliver for free (orders over $35+) within the same day right to your door.

Learn More >>

Live Fish

Beautiful Bettas, Dazzling Danios, Gorgeous Glofish and even MORE in Store! Selection Varies by location.


Live Small Pets

Stop in to find your new feathery friend, cuddly companion or scaly sidekick! Species selection varies by location.


Dog Wash

Self-service dog wash - Everything you need to wash and dry your dog

Learn More >>


Regular grooming keeps your pets looking good and is important to maintaining their good health

Learn More >>


Save at least 35% off your first order. Stay enrolled and receive sale pricing, plus an additional 5% off all future orders. Savings apply to eligible products.

Learn More >>

Events & Specials

Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Aug 07, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Aug 21, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Sep 04, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Sep 18, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM

Meet the Team

(and their pets)

Cassandra Fisher


Lauren Zelle

Shift Supervisor

Shaina Updegraff

Store Team Lead

Need Help?

Get more info about your Pet Supplies Plus questions.


Get answers right away by reading our FAQs.


Contact your local store for assistance.


Fill out a short form and our corporate office will get back to you!