New Albany Pet Store | Pet Supplies Plus

About this Store

We are located on the corner of Morse Rd and Hamilton Rd. We are in the plaza between Stein Mart and The Dollar Tree. Alaina Kramer is the Store Team Leader. She has been with Pet Supplies Plus since 2008. She has four dogs named Gryphon, Dinkie, Cookie and Lucy. She also has two cats named Chino and Wylie. Tucker Merkle is the Assistant Store Team Leader. He has been with Pet Supplies Plus since 2017. He has a Chihuahua named Benny and two cats named Violet and Isabel.



Buy Online Pickup in Store

Buy online and pick up when it is convenient for you. Come on in, or we will bring it to your car. It is easy, fast and best of all free!

Learn More >>

Live Small Pets

Stop in to find your new feathery friend, cuddly companion or scaly sidekick! Species selection varies by location.


Live Crickets

Our cricket IN STOCK GUARANTEE makes sure your critter always has the nutrition they need!


Live Fish

Beautiful Bettas, Dazzling Danios, Gorgeous Glofish and even MORE in Store! Selection Varies by location.


Deliver from Store

Shop online and have your local store deliver it right to your door.

Learn More >>

Events & Specials

Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Mar 13, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Mar 27, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Apr 10, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Veterinary Clinic
Sat - Apr 24, 2021 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM

Meet the Team

(and their pets)

Alaina & Cookie

Store Team Lead

Paige & Rhett

Team Member

Need Help?

Get more info about your Pet Supplies Plus questions.


Get answers right away by reading our FAQs.


Fill out a short form and our corporate office will get back to you!