Elizabethtown Pet Store | Pet Supplies Plus

Independently owned and operated

About this Store

America's Favorite Neighborhood Pet Center in Elizabethtown opened November 13, 2015 in the Towne Centre, just down from Kroger's. This location is a locally-owned store by Curtis Otjen, a veteran, and his wife, Renee. Curtis, Renee, their nephew, Mathew, and their niece, Amber, operate the store, along with knowledgeable team members, who are as passionate as they are about people and their pets. Renee and Curtis get a lot of expert advice from their golden retrievers, Bailey, Luna, and Gilda and their lab, Savannah. The store partners with local rescue groups, including Hardin County Animal Shelter, the Bun Bun Brigade Rabbit Rescue, Always Faithful Rescue, and Forever Homes For Paws who often host weekend adoption events. Other 501C rescues are encouraged to contact Renee if they are interested in conducting future adoption events.



Live Fish

Beautiful Bettas, Dazzling Danios, Gorgeous Glofish and even MORE in Store! Selection Varies by location.


Live Crickets

Our cricket IN STOCK GUARANTEE makes sure your critter always has the nutrition they need!


Live Small Pets

Stop in to find your new feathery friend, cuddly companion or scaly sidekick! Species selection varies by location.


Self-Serve Dog Wash

Self-service dog wash - Everything you need to wash and dry your dog

Learn More >>


Treat them to Drool-worthy delights from the bakery case


Curbside Pickup

Shop with Curbside Pickup to get what you need in as little as one hour without leaving your car.

Learn More >>


Select Delivery at checkout and your local store will deliver for free (orders over $35+) within the same day right to your door.

Learn More >>


Save at least 35% off your first order. Stay enrolled and receive sale pricing, plus an additional 5% off all future orders. Savings apply to eligible products.

Learn More >>

Visiting Pet Care Clinic

Low cost preventative veterinary care, hours and services vary by location. No appointment necessary.

Learn More >>

Events & Specials

Sat - Sep 25, 2021 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Pet Adoption
Sat - Sep 25, 2021 12:00 PM - 4:00 PM
Sat - Sep 25, 2021 2:00 PM - 4:00 PM
Pet Adoption
Sun - Sep 26, 2021 12:00 PM - 4:00 PM

Meet the Team

(and their pets)

Curtis, Renee, Bailey, Luna, Gilda & Savannah

Store Team Lead

Mathew & Jessie

Assistant Store Team Lead

Need Help?

Get more info about your Pet Supplies Plus questions.


Get answers right away by reading our FAQs.


Contact your local store for assistance.


Fill out a short form and our corporate office will get back to you!