Independently owned and operated


Sun: 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Mon-Sat: 09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Curtis, Renee, Bailey & Luna
Store Team Lead

America's Favorite Neighborhood Pet Center in Elizabethtown opened November 13, 2015 in the Towne Centre, just down from Kroger's. This location is a locally-owned store by Curtis Otjen, a veteran, and his wife, Renee. Curtis, Renee, and their nephew, Mathew, operate the store, along with knowledgeable team members, who are as passionate as they are about people and their pets. Renee and Curtis get a lot of expert advice from their golden retrievers, Bailey, and Luna; while Mathew counts on his german shepherd's, Jessie and Lexie, and bearded dragon, Alduin, to provide their helpful insights. The store partners with local rescue groups, including Hardin County Animal Shelter, Always Faithful Rescue, and the Bun Bun Brigade Rabbit Rescue, who often host weekend adoption events. Other 501C rescues are encouraged to contact Renee if they are interested in conducting future adoption events.

Dog Wash

Self-service dog wash - Everything you need to wash and dry your dog

Live Fish

Selection varies by store

Live Small Pets

Selection varies by store

Live Crickets

Feeder crickets for reptiles

Sep 21, 2017 9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Pet Adoption
Sep 24, 2017 1:00 PM - 5:00 PM

Meet the Team

(and their pets)

Curtis, Renee, Bailey & Luna

Store Team Lead

Mathew & Jessie

Assistant Store Team Lead

Beth & Oreo

Team Member


Jessica S.

Plentiful options, awesome staff, they are my new go-to for my dog's. My toy poodle has a very sensitive tummy and there's a treat that we've had to drive... [More]

Was this review helpful to you?

Olivia B.

Was hoping for a new independent pet store in town...not so much. Pet Supplies Plus is a franchised chain out of Michigan with stores in about 25 states,... [More]

Was this review helpful to you?

Stephen P.

Well i recieved a message from these people and they asked for my number and email to make things right. I gave it to them and i heard nothing from them. A... [More]

Was this review helpful to you?

Save $5 on your next purchase

Remove All