Hello, Neighbor

See what sets us apart from other pet supply retailers as we strive to be America's favorite neighborhood pet store.

Come on over
Natural Foods

Learn more about providing your pet companion a healthier and happier life with our large selection of natural food options.

Go Natural
Made in the USA

It's important to know where your pet's favorite products come from. We proudly feature quality products made in the USA.

Support Local
Let's Have Fun!

Are you and your pet getting enough exercise together? Discover the many benefits of a pet-active lifestyle.

Get Active

Homeless animals need safe and loving homes. Contact your neighborhood Pet Supplies Plus store about local animal adoption events.

Adoptions Details

Join us at your neighborhood Pet Supplies Plus store for exciting promotional, educational, pet health and grooming events.

Events Details

We properly pamper your furry friend with our deluxe cleaning and grooming services offered at select locations.

Grooming Details
Self-Service Pet Wash

Our self-service pet wash stations at select locations are equipped with everything you need to get your pet squeaky clean.

Pet Wash Details

From rambunctious pup to silver-furred sidekick, dig deep into our dog care guide to keep their tails wagging.


Cure your curiosity and pounce on these cat care tips that will make your frolicking feline purr.


Fly away with all the facts and figures on how to tend to your feathered friend.

Find a Store Near You

Dive deep into the aquarium and school yourself on all things fin-related.

Small Animals

Keep their wheels spinning fast with these helpful care tips for your favorite miniature mammal.

Reptiles & Amphibians

From dry to swampy, find out what makes them slither, swim, hop and crawl.


Want to open your own Pet Supplies Plus? Learn how to become part of our rapidly expanding franchise family.

Explore Franchising

We're always looking for talented pet-loving individuals to join our team. Explore corporate, distribution and in-store career opportunities.

Work with us
Company News

Keep up to date with exciting new Pet Supplies Plus store openings, expansions, plans for the future and much more.

See current news
Contact Us

Have something to bark or meow about? We'd love to hear from you. Contact our customer service department today.

Get in Touch


Pet Supplies Plus #9027

Address: 4488 COMMERCIAL DR
NEW HARTFORD, NY 13413-6200
Store Hours:
Mon-Sat 9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM


With hundreds of locations and growing, Pet Supplies Plus offers an exciting variety of in-store career opportunities for all experience levels. Our team members are essential in delivering the Pet Supplies Plus company mission-to be America's favorite neighborhood pet store by providing exceptional service to pets and pet parents.

Search in-store jobs

Events & Specials

Events & Specials Information
VIP Pet Care Clinic Sunday, November 30 4:00 pm - 5:30 pm
Rescue me K-9 1st Saturday of Every Month 12:00 pm - 3:00 pm
Stevan Swan Humane Society 2nd Saturday of Every Month
Wanders Rest Last Saturday of Every Month 1:00 pm - 3:00 pm

Services Offered

Click the links below for pricing information

Meet the Owners

We are located across the street from Toys-R-Us in a building shared with the Sneaker Store on Comercial drive. Tim Lowrie has been the store manager for over 6 years in New Hartford and has been with PSP over 10 years. He has 2 dogs named Matti and Maduro that are full of energy and love to be outside getting their exercise in, and he has a 46 gallon saltwater fish tank. Morganne Bennett is an assistant manager and has been here 3 years. She has a bunny named Luey and is in the process of starting a 55 gallon fish tank. Naomi Curis is also an assistant manager in New Hartford and has been here 3 years but with Pet Supplies Plus for 12 years. Tyler Harvey is our shift manager with a passion for breeding reptiles especially exotic colors of Leopard Geckos that he ships all over the United States. Come check out our groomers Jon St.louis and Nancy Hardy. John has 4 years experiance and Nancy over 30 years experiance each have a love of animals and making them look their best. Stop in and put our experience to the test, our team would love to answer all your questions.