Product Names

The product name of a dog food may be the most important factor in your buying decision. Names are featured prominently on dog food labels; they are the first things that you notice when scanning shelves in the dog food aisle, and they serve as a quick reference guide for you to follow. Many pet owners will “shop specific ingredients” when looking for dog food. They’ll seek out turkey, fish, chicken, liver or some other ingredient when determining what to feed their pet. For this reason, dog food manufacturers will typically feature a key ingredient in the names of their products, such as “Turkey Dinner” or “Beef Stew.”

Dog food customers scan the names on the labels to determine which foods to feed their dogs. This system sounds simple enough, but just like you can’t judge a book by its cover, the names on dog food labels can be misleading if you don’t know how to read them. Words like “fish,” “chicken,” and “turkey” can mean very different things in terms of the actual make-up of a dog food, depending on what other words appear with them on the label.

This is why it’s so important for you to learn the language of labels when choosing dog food. AAFCO has four basic rules that govern how language can be used on a dog food label.

1. The 95% Rule – When a food includes the name of a meat ingredient by itself, such as “Turkey For Dogs” or “Beef Dog Food,” at least 95% of the food must be made up of that key meat. So Lamb Dog Food must be 95% lamb by total weight. This does not count condiments and water, which is added for processing. If water is added for processing, the main named ingredient must still account for 70% of the food’s total weight. If the label combines two main ingredients, such as “Chicken and Duck for Dogs,” the two ingredients together must account for 95% of the food’s total weight. In this case, the first ingredient listed in the product’s name must be the one that is more prevalent in the food. So, using our above example, there would be more chicken than duck in a “Chicken and Duck” dog food, and together these two meats would account for 95% of the food’s total weight.
The 95% rule applies only to animal matter, not plant matter. So, if the label says “Lamb and Rice Dog Food,” it must still contain at least 95% lamb.
2. The 25% Rule – Dog foods that have at least 25% of a key ingredient, but less than 95% by weight, can name that ingredient on their label, as long as it is accompanied by a descriptive term like “platter” “dinner,” “formula” “entrée,” or similar wording. So “Chicken Dinner” or “Chicken Platter” dog food is made up of 25% or more of chicken. This 25% figure cannot count the water used for processing, according to AAFCO standards. Unlike the 95% rule, the 25% rule applies to all ingredients, whether they’re plant or animal matter. When two ingredients are listed in the product name the first one must make up a larger percentage of the food formula. So, a “Lamb and Rice Dinner” dog food, must be at least 25% lamb and rice combined, with more lamb than rice.
3. The 3% Rule –  If more than one ingredient is used in a food, it must be listed on the label according to the prevalence (by weight) in that food. Each named ingredient must contribute at least 3% by weight of the food’s content. So when your customers see a label that reads, “Beef, Chicken and Liver Dinner” dog food, they will know that it has at least 25% combined beef, chicken and liver, that it has more beef than chicken or liver, more chicken than liver, and that each ingredient listed contributed at least 3% to its weight total. The 3% rule also applies to food products that are added to the main ingredient. For example, if a manufacturer adds cheese to a turkey dinner, the label can read “Turkey Dinner With Cheese,” provided cheese makes up at least 3% of the weight of the food. Your customers should be aware that the “with” labeling provision also applies to meats that are added in 3% quantities. For example “Salmon Dog Food” must be at least 95% salmon, but “Dog Food With Salmon” could be any dog food formula as long as 3% of it by weight is made up of salmon. This is an important distinction for your customers to recognize when evaluating dog food options.
4. The “Flavor” Rule – If a dog food uses an ingredient before the word “flavor,” it means that there has to be only a “sufficient detectable” amount of that flavor in the formula. There is no requirement that the food have any digestible source of that food. So “Beef Flavored” or “Chicken Flavored” dog food does not have to have any beef or chicken. Most often this flavor is imparted to the food by “meal” or “by-products.” In some cases a “digest” will be used to create a food’s flavor. A digest is a processed material that contains concentrated natural flavors.
 

Terms such as “premium,” “super premium” and “gourmet” are used by dog food manufacturers to distinguish their products, but these terms and claims are not covered by any regulations. They may be fine foods, but their names alone are not guarantee of superior nutritional benefits.